Select Page
Back JimRengePiprahwa • en.wikipedia.org

Top edits to an page All edits made to a page by one user, in chronological order.

Page Piprahwa (Log · Page History)
User JimRenge (Edit Counter· Top Edits)
Total edits 100
Minor edits 5 (5%)
(Semi-)automated edits 20 (20%)
Reverted edits 3 (3%)
atbe1 36.8
Added (bytes)2 6,382
Deleted (bytes) -8,396
Minor edits · 5 (5%)
Major edits · 95 (95%)
(Semi-)automated edits · 20 (20%)
Manual edits · 80 (80%)
Reverted edits · 3 (3%)
Unreverted edits · 97 (97%)
1 Average time between edits (days)
2 Added text is any positive addition that wasn't reverted (approximate)
Date Links Size Edit summary
Diff · History 0 Passing of the Buddha: sp
Diff · History 4 Distribution of the relics: gem relics
Diff · History -1 name consistent with article tile
Diff · History -41 Undid revision 1057186895 by Ph.Bha (talk) per WP:NPOV
Diff · History -278 Undid revision 972328047 by 103.75.49.100 (talk) rvv
Diff · History 24 Undid revision 972329624 by 103.75.49.100 (talk) rvv
Diff · History -306 Undid revision 972326306 by 103.75.49.100 (talk) rvv
Diff · History 14 (reverted)  Undid revision 958372402 by Rajeetmangrati (talk) Lumbini, Nepal that is believed to be the place of Gautama Buddha's birth
Diff · History -2 Distribution of the relics: m
Diff · History 3 Undid revision 907658164 by 120.18.8.252 (talk) rvv
Diff · History 43 added Category:Buddhist archaeological sites using HotCat
Diff · History 17 See also: + Bhattiprolu
Diff · History -253 removed sentence from the lead, per WP:LEAD
Diff · History 2 moved ===Controversy and forgery claims=== section to "excavation by Peppe", claims of forgery appear to be limited to the authenticity of the inscription
Diff · History -125 Excavations by the Archaeological Survey of India: rm redundant sentence
Diff · History 252 Sources: + source
Diff · History 52 Distribution of the relics: paraphrased quote, removed primary source, improved vague Reuters cite, formatting
Diff · History -92 Controversy and forgery claims: removed WP:PUFFERY: said to be the "world's foremost expert" in ancient Indian languages and history),
Diff · History 54 Controversy and forgery claims: tagged unsourced claim, suppl. source with url
Diff · History 38 Distribution of the relics: corr. source date, suppl. url; rm unsourced claim
Diff · History -408 Distribution of the relics: supplemented source, summarized statement
Diff · History 75 Reverted to revision 810942777 by 65.28.236.17 (talk): Per [WP:NPOV]]. (TW)
Diff · History -49 Undid revision 783889756 by 77.76.77.154 (talk) per WP:EL; no evidence that http://www.piprahwa.com is a reliable source
Diff · History -46 Undid revision 783440042 by Thestanfordbuddhist (talk) rm per WP:USERGENERATED and WP:ELER
Diff · History 80 External links: + ASI old link; see talk
Diff · History 43 fixed dead link: + archived version to Kapilavastu Museum
Diff · History 1 Excavation by William Claxton Peppe: moved Dani statement
Diff · History -61 restored text /source integrity
Diff · History -321 External links: cleanup per WP:EL and WP:USERGENERATED. Please see the talk page for a more detailed explanation.
Diff · History 81 created "See also" section
Diff · History -72 Reverted to revision 780112918 by JimRenge (talk): One should generally avoid providing external links to blogs and personal websites per {{WP:EL]]. (TW)
Diff · History -73 (reverted)  Undid revision 780069598 by Kapilmus (talk) rm blog: [http://piprahwadebunk.com/ Debunking the Piprahwa Conspiracy Theory] per WP:EL and WP:SPAM
Diff · History -190 Excavation by William Claxton Peppe: corr. sentence, rm {{citation needed|date=April 2016}} per WP:BURDEN
Diff · History 21 suppl link
Diff · History -91 Reverted to revision 715842804 by Dharmadax (talk): Removed link to blog http://piprahwadebunk.com per WP:EL and WP:SPAM. (TW)
Diff · History 3 minor corr.
Diff · History 15 Sources: corr ext link
Diff · History 84 Excavations by the Archaeological Survey of India: + detail + ref
Diff · History 104 Excavations by the Archaeological Survey of India: + detail
Diff · History -94 sfn
Diff · History 2 Excavations by the Archaeological Survey of India: + wikilink
Diff · History -65 moved info about museum to "Excavations by the ASI" section + ref. Removed unsourced sentence. WP:NOT
Diff · History 30 moved unsourced description of stupa to "Excavations by ASI" section; tagged with citation needed
Diff · History -168 Reverted to revision 684426722 by Aerobert (talk): Per WP:NPOV. (TW)
Diff · History -31 removed wikilink to Thomas William Rhys Davids because the more important link to the SAOS online source did not work after the intro of the wikilink
Diff · History 533 Excavation by William Claxton Peppe: revert removal of sourced content, Ahmad Hasan Dani´s conclusion
Diff · History 43 Sources: + stable ext. link in ref
Diff · History -164 Involvement of Alois Anton Führer: remove sentence: It was six weeks before he finally arrived .... Unsourced, please see WP:BURDEN and WP:OR
Diff · History -61 Involvement of Alois Anton Führer: removed: And, although he has not published any work on the subject ... Unsourced, please see WP:BURDEN, WP:NPOV
Diff · History -115 Involvement of Alois Anton Führer: rm: However, while no one today challenges the inscription’s meaning ... Please see WP:RS/AC.
Diff · History -216 Reverted to revision 682434692 by JimRenge (talk): Sorry, http://news-antique.com/?id=805825 is not a reliable source, Please see WP:VeriFy, WP:RS and WP:USERGENERATED. (TW)
Diff · History 30 (reverted)  Undid revision 682733383 by DeputyDoig (talk) removal of a reliable source (Smith) and addition of unsourced content. Please see WP:BURDEN
Diff · History -130 Undid revision 682432724 by Taphelps (talk) unsourced addition of content; if you'd like to include a citation and re-add it, please do so
Diff · History -108 Reverted to revision 680407682 by 64.239.143.22 (talk): Removed blog: http://piprahwajewels.co.uk/ per WP:EL. (TW)
Diff · History -49 sourced statement
Diff · History 604 + note, Bloch: "The bones (...) according to my opinion were not human bones at all."
Diff · History -1 Excavation by William Claxton Peppe: translated by Bühler
Diff · History 10 Excavation by William Claxton Peppe: detail: Brahmi inscription
Diff · History -29 Sources: corr refs
Diff · History -52 rm unsourced cmt; + ref
Diff · History 172 Excavation by William Claxton Peppe: added Fleet´s translation/interpretation of the inscription + refs; removed unsourced cmt: "It is not clear whether the inscription specifically refers to Buddha's half-brother ..."
Diff · History 27 corr. ref: Smith´s note in Peppe´s article
Diff · History -4 Excavation by William Claxton Peppe: more cautious: ...implying that "the depositors believed" the bone fragments were part of the remains of Gautama Buddha. Ref. Note by VA Smith in Peppe 1898
Diff · History 575 Quote from Willis review of Falk´s new book: "As the question of fakes is raised by Falk himself, it is noteworthy that the author has side-stepped the Piprahwa reliquary in the India Museum, Calcutta, in all likelihood a forgery made by A. A. Führer
Diff · History 16 Sources: suppl. refs
Diff · History 63 + photo: stupa
Diff · History 7 Excavations by the Archaeological Survey of India: caption
Diff · History -4 typo, rm redlink
Diff · History 430 better source: includes Führers letters
Diff · History 57 added photography of exvacations
Diff · History -415 tried to improve the structure: created "Exvacation by William Claxton Peppe" section (I have summarized the arguments against suspicion of forgery by Führer in a new subsection), created "Exvacations by the Archaeological Survey of India" section
Diff · History 233 added content to the lede
Diff · History 10 Archeological association with Gautama Buddha: + detail
Diff · History 3 typo
Diff · History 399 clarified + refs
Diff · History 252 sourced info
Diff · History -440 corr. refs
Diff · History -66 m corr
Diff · History 36 moved note to corresp. section; compact {{Reflist|3|refs=}}
Diff · History 24 improved refs
Diff · History -622 formatting refs
Diff · History -1,180 formatting refs
Diff · History 221 improving refs
Diff · History 312 Michael Willis also thinks the reliquary to be a forgery + ref
Diff · History 253 Archeological association with Gautama Buddha: + ref: Andrew Huxley´s Inaugural Lecture, SOAS
Diff · History -21 Archeological association with Gautama Buddha: WP:CREDENTIALS
Diff · History 41 suppl. webref
Diff · History 117 External links: + [http://kapilavastumuseum.in/Kapilavastums/about_us Kapilavastu Museum], Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) 2015
Diff · History 232 created External links section, + link
Diff · History 260 Location of ancient Kapilavastu: + ref
Diff · History -659 removed duplicate text about Kapilavastu, created "Location of ancient Kapilavastu" section
Diff · History -685 rm text: sourced with a blog http://www.piprahwa.org.uk/|website=piprahwa.org.uk/ doubts about the validity of the exvacation/authenticity of the relics need to be verified by published! secondary academic sources
Diff · History -3 corr
Diff · History -174 Archeological association with Gautama Buddha: rm blog: [http://piprahwajewels.co.uk/page3.html], {{Citation needed}}, WP:VERIFY, WP:RS
Diff · History 115 Undid revision 667325773 by Dharmadax (talk) Please see WP:OR, WP:VERIFY
Diff · History -84 Reverted to revision 660744243 by JimRenge (talk): Edit damaged cite format + introduced a dead ext. link. Please see WP:CITE, WP:RS, WP:EL. (TW)
Diff · History -4 WP:NPOV
Diff · History -81 improved refs and ext. links
Diff · History 309 + ref.
Diff · History -335 Archeological association with Gautama Buddha: rm sellf-pubished sources. Added {{Citation needed}}
All times are in UTC.